Sappy Stories
Wednesday, September 17, 2008

I spent a good portion of a recent Saturday morning researching publishing houses for a picture book I'd like to see in print. It's a concept that came to me about seven years ago when my daughter had one of those profound—only kids could say that—moments. I immediately wrote down her thought and got to work.

So many years later this book still sits in various layers on my desk: critique groups have looked at; I have labored over the words and constantly revised it; and my agent even read through it, then turned it down saying, "there's just not enough punch—and it rhymes—it won't sell..."

I come from Basque heritage—do you know who the Basques are? They're a sort of wild, renegade people who live between France and Spain in the Pyrenees mountains. They've been known for many things like handball and dancing on top of wine glasses and playing tug of war and singing long ballads, but I think they're better known for smuggling and blowing things up. (I do not condone blowing things up, just so you know! More about that next.) From the Basques I think I get a certain bulldog quality. I am stubborn and tenacious, and don't give up easily on stories that I've labored over, and I like to sing long ballads and watch people dance on top of wine glasses, too...

I also am Danish and Irish and Scottish and English and a tiny bit German. I think all these other blood mixes formed in me a sort of peace treaty—they had to for my survival!—and that explains the part of me that loves harmony. As a sister I played mediator between the various family escapades that arose, as a friend I quelled arguments between classmates that had to do with whether the ball in foursquare actually hit the line, and in my stories I have a particular aversion to poisoning, threatening, or lopping off the heads of any of my beloved characters.

Okay, so maybe that begins to explain why yesterday, as I was reading through submission guidelines, and perusing the blogs of young editorial assistants at big houses, that I returned to my little story and suddenly realized, "Yikes! That story that I've now been working on for over seven years (!!!) is pure, sugar-coated, honey-flooded sap!"

What to do? What to do? The Basque in me can not let go, and the Mutt in me seeks a happy solution.

You know, it's weird. When I put on my editor's hat, I am a good Sap Spotter. One whiff of it sends me straight into rejection letter mode. (And as I'm sure you can guess, you will never get a nicer rejection letter than from me :) ) But with my own stuff, I goo and ooze, and just can't migrate to the conflict side of things! Until I learn this lesson, I'm afraid, I will forever be revising some of these adventure tales that I've dreamed up. All those words, all that time... Help me, I'm drowning in my own sweetness!

At a conference once, I climbed a long set of stairs to a podium, perched in front of a large audience, where I read the first chapter of a story for a critique. I stood poised, and read well, despite the nervous twitter of the paper in my hands. I loved this novel and thought I had got the book off to a snappy start. "Well," began the prof who was critiquing. "Do you drink much caffeine?" he asked bluntly.
"No sir, I don't."
"The words are lovely, the phrases flow from one thought to the next with ease and grace and elegance, but you're too nice. You had me in a trance. You suffer from niceness and I recommend you get a good strong cup of something before you sit down at your computer to compose."
"Umm, okay," I muttered. "Thanks."

So there you have it. A recommendation of Performance Enhancing Drugs. If I want to succeed in this business, and do more than write lovely rejection letters, I better get some caffeine and fast.

Any thoughts on a cure? I really don't do coffee—it gets me all fluttery. Any news on inventions of Sapometers? Any of you ever written a sappy story?

Okay, enough of this blabbering. I have a story to rewrite. Seven years is nothing to a Basque; I'm gonna hole up in a mountain town and herd my words until they're zippin' and fightin' their way off the page!

Comments (8)
Seraphima says:
September 22, 2008
"You asked for comment--and ME, turn down an opportunity to say something?! Nada chance. Okay; yesterday you said we're both bulldogs. So what do we do when the sap gets sticky? We start cutting it with turpentine. Okay; baby oil works for some people. Remember Praxis? You know what I did? I got ruthless. I attacked those over-inflated adjectives with karate chops! Buh-bye third-time read, over-used flabberjabber! No mercy! It was hard, but in the end it strengthened what I wanted to say, and I believe it made the article so much better. Now I realize articles and stories are of very different ilk, but there is that inner Sapometer you already know you have, so you have to give it permission to come out. Save your original. It can be safely tucked away where you can enjoy it whenever you like. (Does this sound familiar?) But let your inner red-inker help you get through this one, and see if in the end you might not like it better. Love you, Seraphima "
Carol says:
September 23, 2008
"We nice girls have to work extra hard at this. Conflict and tension move stories forward, even in a picture book. At least one other member of our first critique group got told the same thing! Good luck in finding your inner toughness! Carol"
Katherine Hyde says:
September 23, 2008
"Hi, Jane, I hear you, sister! I was always the peacekeeper in my family and I hate to get my characters into trouble. I've been developing my own Sapometer over the years I've been working on my novel. One thing that helped me a lot was going to a workshop where the leader was ruthless about sap. But once it's in a story, it's awfully hard to edit it all out. Another thing that can help is reading contemporary secular fiction. Or, of course, having your life go sour and becoming a cynic--but I really don't recommend that route! "
Carla Harris says:
September 23, 2008
"First of all Bravo for you for getting this blog going, second for fessing up about your tendency for being sappy, and third for asking for help! Of course, I can't help you. I'm definitely not a writer, and also being the peacemaker in my family of origin and constantly wanting to "teach the virtues" I'm all to sappy myself. It seems to me that if you're seeing it yourself, that's a good sign and points to the hopeful fact that you can steer around it. Though...I do wonder if it's possible to write about horrible things if we haven't experienced some of them ourselves. Maybe Katherine has a point...you either need to hear about some of those edgy scenarios or walk through them up-close and personal. I definitely recommend the former! Go, Jane!!! "
Happy says:
September 25, 2008
"Dare I say it? ....I like the sappy stuff! Maybe that's because I'm a let's-talk-about-our-feelings-sit-in-a-circle-and-cry type of person. But I,too, have struggled with my inner peacemaker(is that an oxymoron?)..is it a girl/woman thing?..and does people-pleaser equal peacemaker? I'm not sure, but I think we all just want to love and be loved. Of course my brave, rebellious side wants a say in everything too. As a kid, I used to tag along with my older brother and his friends. I was always used as their crash dummy or tree house test pilot...but never would I allow them to cast me as the damsel in distress or the stewardess. I wanted to be in there riding and flying and fighting like the rest of them!! But there has to be room for this duality in us, doesn't there? In yoga we balance the inner warrior with the more serene reflective self. I think as we journey through life each person struggles to find the right balance for themselves....as for me, I'll take a little extra sappy on the side! thanks Jane. this was fun. you go girl."
Slippery when wet says:
September 26, 2008
"You know what I told you...there has to be other people in this world like that little girl that came up with that incredible wild thought and want to live in that place. Plus, for all of the people that have never had a thought like that-wouldn't you love to give them an ah-ha! moment? Keep the cloud...we all should visit there once in awhile-maybe just bring an umbrella. "
Erin says:
October 1, 2008
"Jane...when I read about how you were standing in front of a large audience and being captive to professor's opinion, I bragged about you to my children! I did just that! It was a, "Hey guys, listen to what Jane did." And they learned something. The poised and accomplished friend of their mother's took a chance, and who would ever think someone would say something like that to Jane G. Meyer? Even more so, that she would actually admit it! You know, when you are being vulnerable and things don't go right, and then you tell other people? That in itself should get you published! I also like to have more good reasons to drink strong coffee, although I'm not sure I need it for the same reasons. I like the caffiene So that is what the kids and I got from"
Mimi says:
April 7, 2009
"I was a bit giddy after you commented on my blog - I feel famous by association, and I've been enjoying reading yours - but since my great-grandfather was Basque, I just had to comment. "
Name:
Email:

Don't worry, I keep your email address private!
Comment: